Pasar al contenido principal
Download

The Association for Progressive Communications (APC) welcomes the opportunity to submit initial comments on this year’s UNGA resolution on “The right to privacy in the digital age”. We appreciate the continued efforts of Brazil and Germany to advance this resolution and involve civil society at this early stage.

APC is an international civil society organisation and a network of members dedicated to empowering and supporting people working for peace, human rights, development and protection of the environment through the strategic use of information and communications technologies (ICTs), including the internet. APC currently has 73 organisational members and 44 associates active in 74 countries, primarily in the Global South.

APC welcomes the progressive agreed language and the significant progress that this resolution has made to clarify the scope of the obligations of states and the responsibilities of companies to respect and protect the right to privacy and other human rights in the digital age. These comments focus on strengthening this language, with a focus on the differentiated impacts of privacy infringements on vulnerable groups, including on human rights defenders (HRDs) and women human rights defenders (WHRDs).

General observations and comments

Cross-cutting: Differentiated impacts of privacy infringements

The UN Special Rapporteur on the right to privacy has recognised that gender, alongside other factors such as ethnicity, beliefs, culture, social origins and age, shapes experiences of privacy [A/HRC/43/52, para. 19(a)].

Similarly, APC’s work highlights the disproportionate impacts of surveillance technologies on gender, sexual and political rights activists, ethnic, racial and religious minorities, journalists and advocates. HRDs, activists and journalists (with women defenders and journalists disproportionately impacted) are regularly subjected to surveillance and have their privacy rights persistently violated online. This is also the case for members of minoritised, criminalised or otherwise marginalised communities.

We encourage the resolution to recognise and address these differentiated impacts by retaining the language on the need for gender-responsive policies to protect the right to privacy.

Surveillance of human rights defenders

APC and members have documented how digital surveillance tools, ranging from commercially sold spyware to sophisticated interception systems and biometric data platforms, have been used by states and non-state actors to monitor, intimidate and suppress civil society, gender, sexual and political minorities, journalists, HRDs and WHRDs.. Research indicates that HRDs and WHRDs are particularly exposed to risks in situations of conflict and instability.

We encourage this new iteration of the resolution to retain language that notes how surveillance, hacking and data collection interfere with the lives of those engaged in the promotion and defence of human rights. This could be an opportunity to strengthen language in relation to refraining from the use of surveillance technologies in a manner that is not compliant with international human rights obligations, including when used against HRDs [HRC/RES/54/21, para. 9(n)].

We suggest building on the Human Rights Council resolution on human rights defenders and new technologies that emphasises the particular risks for the safety of HRDs in the digital age, “including their exposure to unlawful or arbitrary surveillance, unlawful or arbitrary interference with privacy, targeted interception of communications [and] hacking, including government-sponsored hacking” [A/HRC/RES/58/23]. APC recommends that the resolution should condemn the use of spyware and mass surveillance against HRDs and urge states to cease targeted digital surveillance of defenders, and adopt independent oversight mechanisms and transparency rules on surveillance technologies.

The resolution could recognise the particular importance of the right to privacy for WHRDs, who are disproportionately affected by online violence, harassment and surveillance. As stated, we encourage the resolution to retain the language on the need to mainstream a gender perspective into the conceptualisation, development and implementation of digital technologies and related policies and promote the participation of women in all of their diversity.

The resolution could also consider reflecting existing HRC language on the discriminatory impacts of biometric identification technologies, including facial recognition, and recall that states should ensure these technologies are not be used for mass surveillance by public or private actors [HRC resolution 54/21, para. 9(n)]. Additionally, it could encourage greater transparency in the procurement and use of surveillance technologies and join the call of the Special Rapporteur on the right to freedom of expression for a moratorium on the sale, transfer and use of surveillance technology until human rights-compliant safeguards are in place [A/HRC/41/35].

Encryption and anonymity

We recommend considering the strengthening of the language on encryption by recognising its essential role for the exercise of privacy in the digital age, particularly for individuals and groups who are exposed to differentiated impacts of privacy infringements. This resolution could recall that encryption enables journalists, HRDs and others operating in restrictive environments to conduct their work, while also providing protection for women and others facing particular threats of surveillance, harassment and violence online [A/HRC/51/17, para 21].

The right to anonymity is an essential facet of privacy in the online context, especially for WHRDs and/or other criminalised or targeted groups. Digital anonymity allows them to seek information, find solidarity and support, and share opinions without fear of being identified.

We encourage this resolution to call on states to promote measures and technical solutions for strong encryption and anonymity in line with HRC resolution 54/21, para 12, and to encourage business enterprises to enable such technologies. Building on past iterations, this is an opportunity for the resolution to call states to enact policies around encryption and anonymity in line with HRC resolution 58/23, para. 9 (k).

Artificial intelligence

APC recommends that this resolution acknowledge that AI systems rely on large-scale data extraction, often non-consensual, opaque and disproportionately affecting marginalised and underrepresented communities. These practices pose a risk to the right to privacy and disproportionately harm women, LGBTQIA+ people and racialised or poor communities, who are more likely to be subject to intensified surveillance.

APC also recommends that the resolution build on language that recognises that the use of AI without human rights safeguards poses the risk of reinforcing discrimination and structural inequalities [A/HRC/RES/54/21]. The resolution could also call on states to refrain from or cease the use or transfer of new and emerging technologies, including AI applications, that cannot be operated in compliance with international human rights law [A/HRC/RES/58/23].

Private sector role

Given the role of business enterprises in shaping the exercise of the right to privacy, we encourage the resolution to call on states to require independent, transparent and ongoing human rights due diligence, including assessments of the differentiated and intersectional impacts of companies' policies, products and services, with meaningful involvement of civil society and marginalised groups. The resolution could also encourage transparency reporting on privacy-related human rights risks and promote the implementation of privacy by design and by default, including through data minimisation and the integration of privacy safeguards throughout the technology lifecycle.

Conclusion

APC appreciates the continued leadership on this resolution and the opportunity to provide comments. Considering the increasing significance of digital technologies for the right to privacy, we encourage the penholders to strengthen the resolution by addressing the differentiated impacts of digital privacy infringements, including surveillance, on vulnerable groups; recognising the essential role of encryption; reinforcing human rights safeguards in relation to AI; and further addressing the responsibilities of business enterprises in relation to privacy.

 

Footnotes

  1. https://www.apc.org/en/about/who-we-are 
  2. https://www.genderit.org/FPI-paper-on-privacy 
  3. https://www.apc.org/en/pubs/surveillance-industry-and-human-rights-submission-united-nations-special-rapporteur-promotion; https://www.apc.org/en/pubs/submission-association-progressive-communications-special-rapporteur-human-rights-defenders
  4. https://www.apc.org/en/pubs/ecosystem-digital-repression-silencing-women-human-rights-defenders-and-other-pro-democracy
  5. https://www.genderit.org/FPI-paper-on-privacy 
  6. https://www.apc.org/sites/default/files/ai-and-tfgbv-research_final.pdf
  7. https://www.apc.org/en/pubs/apc-submission-un-working-group-business-and-human-rights-issue-procurement-and-deployment-ai
  8. https://www.apc.org/en/pubs/joint-submission-global-digital-compact-gender

 

Read the full submission here

 

Tags

Regions
Areas of work